A lighter material needs a fuller comparison.
An illustrative decision note. This example demonstrates the document system; it does not report research findings.
Define what must stay the same.
Reducing mass is useful only if a part still meets its performance, repair and service-life requirements. Compare candidates under the same conditions before selecting one.
| Requirement | Evidence needed |
|---|---|
| Performance | Comparable load and fatigue results. |
| Repair | Available methods, skills and replacement parts. |
| Recovery | Feasible reuse or material recovery routes. |
Make uncertainty visible.
Keep assumptions beside estimates. A range should explain what varies, rather than imply a statistical confidence level that was never measured.
For the related chart pattern, open the candidate comparison. Keep figures and their readable tables together in the final export.
See the companion chart, “Compare the estimate. Keep the uncertainty.” Read the figures alongside their data table.
Choose a bounded next step.
Define a small trial with explicit acceptance criteria and a named reviewer. Record what would change the decision before collecting more evidence.